WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW
- Psychologist Clarence Leuba began testing whether laughter from tickling was innate or learned in 1933.
- Leuba and his wife tickled their fourth and fifth children while concealing their faces behind a cardboard mask.
- The infants began laughing from tickling between 6 and 7 months of age.
- Leuba concluded that laughter caused by tickling appeared innate, although the children preferred mild tickling and resisted sustained vigorous sessions.
Scientists have sometimes gone to remarkable lengths to test ideas, including questions whose stakes were far from monumental. Among the stranger examples is psychologist Clarence Leuba, who in 1933 began investigating whether laughter caused by tickling was innate or learned through social cues.
Before Leuba’s masked experiment came Dr Donald Unger’s unusual study, which began in 1948. For 50 years, Unger cracked every knuckle on his left hand while leaving those on his right untouched, ultimately recording 36,500 cracks.
"Knuckle cracking did not lead to arthritis after a 50-year controlled study by the one participant," Unger wrote. He acknowledged that a larger group would be needed to confirm his preliminary finding, given his sample size of one.
Leuba pursued a different curiosity. "More specifically," he wrote in a resulting paper, "we sought to discover whether or not laughter would appear in response to tickling, as an aspect of the maturational process independently of any association with other laughter provoking stimuli."
In practical terms, Leuba wanted to know whether children spontaneously laughed when tickled or learned the response by watching smiling and laughing parents. Answering that question required a tickling device and extended access to infants.
Leuba had both. He used a tickling tassel and enlisted his fourth and fifth children as subjects, observing them during their first year of life while attempting to strip away the social signals normally associated with playful tickling.
Leuba and his wife established strict conditions for the experiment. The children could be tickled only during designated sessions, never while another visible person was laughing or while the child was already laughing because of another game.
During each session, the experimenter targeted familiar ticklish areas, including the armpits, the backs of the knees and the neck. Tickling began softly before becoming more vigorous as the children’s reactions were observed.
The sessions also required a peculiar disguise. "Before approaching the infant, the experimenter always concealed his face behind a 12" by 15" piece of cardboard, having a narrow slit in front of each eye through which the infant could be observed," Leuba explained.
The experimenter attempted to maintain a sober expression behind the cardboard shield. Although the babies could not see that expression, the mask prevented them from responding to a visible smile or other facial encouragement.
At first, the male and female infants showed little response beyond some squirming. Both developed laughter in reaction to other stimuli, but laughter caused by tickling did not emerge until they were between 6 and 7 months old.
Despite the unnerving mask and rigid setup, the children appeared to enjoy at least some of the sessions. They tried to grasp the experimenter’s fingers, and the boy later attempted to pull the fingers back while requesting "more tickling" once he had the vocabulary.
Their enjoyment had clear limits. Mild and intermittent tickling appeared pleasurable, while sustained vigorous tickling, especially around the ribs and armpits, produced violent bodily movements and eventually crying.
"Both babies seemed to enjoy mild, intermittent tickling and to dread sustained tickling," Leuba wrote. The children used their hands to control the experimenter’s fingers, seeking more of the gentler sensation and less of the intense version.
Once the children understood the activity, raised fingers alone became enough to prompt giggling. The article compares this association to an inverse version of the Little Albert experiment, in which a baby was conditioned to fear fluffy objects, including rabbits, dogs and a Santa Claus mask.
Leuba’s main finding was that laughter in response to tickling appeared to be innate rather than learned. The social setting still mattered, as Charles Darwin observed: "in that of laughter from being tickled the mind must be in a pleasurable condition; a young child, if tickled by a strange man, would scream in fear."
The precise benefit of the tickle response remains unclear. Light tickling, known as knismesis, may help detect creepy crawlies on the skin, while heavier tickling, called gargalesis, has been linked by some ideas to social bonding, humor development or early life combat training.
One paper offered an evolutionary possibility: "Thus, the discomfort and pleasure elicited by tickling might be adaptive and help a child develop skills that can be used in defense and combat." Leuba’s masked family experiment provided early evidence that infants develop the laughter response without visible encouragement.
Join the Discussion
COMMENTS POLICY: We have no tolerance for messages of violence, racism, vulgarity, obscenity or other such discourteous behavior. Thank you for contributing to a respectful and useful online dialogue.