WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW
- Ginnifer died hours after birth when her family relied on prayer instead of emergency medical care.
- Police compelled the family to hospitalize her twin, Evelyn, who survived respiratory distress syndrome with intensive treatment.
- Former Follower Marshall Phillips received guardianship after testifying that he had previously saved his son by seeking hospital care.
- Evelyn now receives medical care, visits her twin’s grave and maintains contact with both the Phillipses and her birth parents.
On March 5, 2017, deputy medical examiner Eric Tonsfeldt entered a pistachio green house in Oregon City and found Sarah Mitchell holding her dead newborn, Ginnifer. Mitchell, a member of the Followers of Christ, had received no prenatal care, and three women without medical training had guided the delivery.
Family members claimed Ginnifer appeared healthy before suddenly stopping breathing, but their answers struck Tonsfeldt as vague. Investigators later discovered that Followers began exchanging worried messages 13 minutes after her birth, including “Not good breathing” and “She’s really bad.”
Nobody called 911 as Ginnifer’s breathing deteriorated. Her father later explained, “Because it’s in God’s hands.” He anointed her with olive oil and prayed before she died in his arms at 7 p.m., four hours after her birth.
Ginnifer weighed 3½ pounds, roughly half the weight of an average full term infant. Tonsfeldt found no injury, but while he delayed his departure by requesting coffee, one grandfather revealed that Ginnifer had a twin.
In a dim bathroom, Tonsfeldt found women surrounding Evelyn, a nearly silent newborn being fed with an eyedropper. When the family refused his demand to take her to a hospital, police arrived and warned that they would transport her themselves.
The family relented, and a patrol car followed them to the hospital. Evelyn entered a neonatal intensive care unit in Portland with respiratory distress syndrome, where a breathing machine and feeding tube helped stabilize her.
An autopsy concluded that the same condition, which is common among premature babies, caused Ginnifer’s death. The Mitchells faced murder by neglect charges and criminal mistreatment allegations for failing to obtain medical care for Evelyn.
Authorities then had to decide who would care for the surviving twin. Evelyn’s family proposed Marshall and Jennifer Phillips, a couple raised in the Followers, but Marshall had previously broken with the sect’s expectations by taking his gravely ill son to a hospital.
Marshall’s decision came during the summer of 2013, when his 11 year old son, Nick, became lethargic and struggled to breathe. Marshall feared prosecution if he refused medical care, but he also knew that relatives expected him to rely entirely on faith.
“I’m taking him to the hospital,” Marshall announced before carrying Nick from the house. Doctors diagnosed acute onset Type 1 diabetes and said his blood was becoming acidic, his organs were shutting down and he was only hours from death without treatment.
The decision isolated the Phillips family from relatives and church members. Marshall became depressed and searched the Bible for a prohibition against medical care, but instead found references portraying physicians with respect.
Marshall eventually concluded that God could heal through doctors. When Evelyn’s custody reached a Clackamas County circuit judge, he testified about saving Nick, said his son was thriving and promised that Evelyn would receive medical treatment.
The state placed Evelyn with the Phillipses. She had been born about eight weeks early, weighed less than 4 pounds and remained in the neonatal intensive care unit for 11 days before leaving the hospital.
In summer 2018, Sarah and Travis Mitchell pleaded guilty to criminally negligent homicide in Ginnifer’s death and criminal mistreatment for failing to obtain help for Evelyn. Their agreement required six years and six months in prison, the harshest sentence imposed on parents in the sect.
The Phillipses later attended an evangelical Christian church and were baptized in the Willamette River in October 2018. Their departure from the Followers cost them relationships, including Marshall’s connection with his mother, who sent him a goodbye message after the baptism.
Evelyn, now 9, visits Ginnifer’s grave each birthday and maintains contact with her birth parents twice a month. She was recently baptized, receives pediatric care and is current on vaccines, while the Mitchells are seeking expanded visitation after withdrawing an effort to end the Phillipses’ permanent guardianship.
Join the Discussion
COMMENTS POLICY: We have no tolerance for messages of violence, racism, vulgarity, obscenity or other such discourteous behavior. Thank you for contributing to a respectful and useful online dialogue.