WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW
- Federal guidelines effective Nov. 18 add safeguards for donation after circulatory death.
- Families, providers and others may request a pause, with new procedures for reporting and documenting interruptions.
- Organ recovery must wait at least five minutes after circulation stops.
- Experts welcomed clearer protections but raised concerns about family pressure, consistent enforcement and independent neurological assessments.
New federal organ donation guidelines took effect Nov. 18, changing procedures for some donors after reported cases raised serious questions about whether organ recovery had begun before death was confirmed. The update focuses on stronger patient safeguards, clearer family communication and more consistent documentation.
The Health Resources and Services Administration, a branch of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, previously announced the policy update in a press release. The Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network approved the changes in August.
The guidelines apply to donation after circulatory death, known as DCD, in which organs are recovered after the heart and lungs stop functioning. That process differs from donation after brain death, when a donor is declared dead based on the irreversible loss of brain function.
A formal process will allow donation procedures to be paused when concerns about patient safety arise. Families, medical providers and other people involved must be informed that they can request a pause and told how to make that request.
The rules also establish procedures for handling and reporting unplanned pauses. They require more detailed records of neurological assessments and a waiting period of at least five minutes after circulation stops before organ recovery can begin.
The changes are intended to strengthen safeguards and improve communication, but one bioethicist raised concerns about when families might be approached. University of Rochester bioethicist Dr. Lainie Ross told NPR that contact from organ procurement teams before a decision to withdraw life sustaining care could make families feel pressured or distrustful of doctors’ motives.
In public comments, the American Society of Transplantation supported honoring requests to pause the donation process at any point. Previous cases in which organ recovery reportedly began before confirmation of death have fueled questions about existing protections.
HRSA Division of Transplantation Director Dr. Raymond Lynch told Fox News Digital that premature organ recovery "does not happen" under the process governed by the updated guidelines. He said the policies are meant to preserve the sanctity of the donation decision while ensuring that the technical aspects of the operation pose no risk to the patient.
Lynch said the guidelines improve the "safety, quality and consistency of care that's already being delivered across the United States." He also noted that organ donation practices have changed within the past decade.
Historically, most donors were declared dead based on brain death and were legally deceased when the donation decision was made, according to Lynch. DCD involves individuals who are not brain dead but are very severely injured.
In those circumstances, the medical team and family decide to change the goals of care and allow the patient to have a natural, compassionate death. After the patient dies, the organs are removed through a surgical procedure.
The guidelines do not change the roles of the patient’s healthcare team or the organ procurement organization, which coordinates organ donation and recovery. Instead, they clarify expectations for when discussions and procedures connected to donation should occur.
Lynch said donation conversations historically happened very late in a patient’s medical course, creating two potential harms. Families could feel "rushed or pressured" to authorize donation, while delays could deny patients the opportunity to donate as they intended when registering as donors.
Another risk was the insufficient delivery of information and inadequate recording of decisions. The updated rules call for more thorough conversations and clearer documentation of what information families received and when it was shared.
Lynch noted that these conversations occur during tragic circumstances, when families and loved ones are experiencing fear and grief. HRSA aims to make the quality and quantity of communication and medical care "very high," while promoting professionalism, consistency, compassion and respect.
Dr. Stephanie Widmer, a New York City emergency medicine physician and Fox News medical contributor, called the changes a positive step toward improving patient safety, transparency and public trust. She said families should understand the clearer safeguards, including the five minute wait and the ability to pause the process.
Widmer cautioned that a policy is "only as effective as its implementation" and questioned whether the safeguards would be consistently enforced across hospitals and organ procurement organizations. She called for stronger national standards for independent neurological assessments and greater oversight of organ procurement practices.
"The medical team caring for the patient should remain completely independent of the organ recovery process," she emphasized. Widmer also said families deserve clear explanations of what will happen, including any specialized procedures used to preserve organs.
Join the Discussion
COMMENTS POLICY: We have no tolerance for messages of violence, racism, vulgarity, obscenity or other such discourteous behavior. Thank you for contributing to a respectful and useful online dialogue.