WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW
- Videos allegedly showing pterodactyls above Ciudad Juárez circulated online and attracted believers.
- Snopes identified strangely changing text as a major indication that the footage was generated using AI.
- Evan the Dino Guy said the creature resembles an inaccurate, outdated reconstruction of Pteranodon longiceps.
- Palaeontologist Evan Jevnikar said its wing movement and alleged location do not fit Pteranodon.
Videos circulating online have convinced some viewers that pterodactyls are flying over Chihuahua, Mexico. A palaeontologist and other dinosaur enthusiasts have now picked apart the extraordinary claim, pointing to both digital clues and glaring problems with the creature itself.
The first videos appeared on journalist Jaime Maussan’s YouTube channel, according to the debunking website Snopes. They allegedly showed a flying prehistoric creature above Ciudad Juárez in Chihuahua.
Maussan has previously promoted similarly unusual claims. He presented what turned out to be the corpse of a human child as a potential extraterrestrial and later took another purported alien to the Mexican Congress.
His videos were accompanied by stories allegedly originating with a child who claimed to have seen a pterodactyl attempting to abduct a dog. According to that account, the creature failed and flew away.
More footage began circulating after those videos appeared. “Some Mexican citizens claim to have captured a pterodactyl flying through the night sky over Ciudad Juárez, Chihuahua, Mexico,” one Instagram account explained.
“Videos circulating online show a large, dark, winged silhouette that has sparked speculation about the possible sighting of a prehistoric creature. Some have pointed out its unusual shape, while skeptics believe it could be a large bird or digitally altered footage.”
The account also acknowledged the immense problem confronting the claim. “Pterosaurs have been extinct for approximately 66 million years, but that hasn’t stopped the speculation online.”
That extinction date has not prevented some people from apparently believing the videos. Yet skepticism is particularly warranted at a time when AI generated images and videos can produce convincing but entirely artificial scenes.
Snopes identified the behavior of text in one video as a major sign that it was generated using AI. The text changes from an illegible blur into readable text within moments, which is not how text behaves in authentic footage.
There is also the more obvious issue that the video supposedly contains a creature that disappeared 66 million years ago. Palaeontologists who noticed the footage were not impressed by its labeling as a pterodactyl either.
Science communicator and dinosaur enthusiast Evan the Dino Guy, who runs the Dino Guy YouTube channel, said the creature more closely resembles Pteranodon longiceps. Even then, he found the reconstruction deeply unconvincing.
“This does not look like a good Pteranodon longiceps reconstruction,” Evan said. “Instead, it looks like one that you would see in old stop motion dinosaur films like The Valley of Gwangi.”
MORE NEWS: Fiona the Hippo Faces a Terrifying Crisis After Swallowing a Hat: Surgery Could Be Deadly
The AI generated animal resembles older reconstructions, according to Evan. It appears too skinny and lacks the “pycnofibers,” or small feathers, that scientists believe Pteranodon longiceps would have possessed.
Palaeontologist Evan Jevnikar identified another problem on Instagram. The creature would not flap its wings in the manner shown, a point that can be appreciated by watching modern birds glide.
Its supposed location also fails to fit where Pteranodon would have lived in ancient times. “Pteranodons were very common in the American Midwest back when it was an ancient seaway. And these sightings have been in Chihuahua, Mexico, which is nowhere close to a seaway or an ocean or any type of environment that a Pteranodon would most likely live in,” Jevnikar said.
“It’s not even close to where you would find fossils of a Pteranodon.” The videos therefore offer no credible evidence that pterodactyls or any other extinct ancient creatures are flying above Mexico, while their digital and anatomical flaws provide ample reasons for doubt.
WATCH BELOW:
Join the Discussion
COMMENTS POLICY: We have no tolerance for messages of violence, racism, vulgarity, obscenity or other such discourteous behavior. Thank you for contributing to a respectful and useful online dialogue.