WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW
- Adults produced more novel and effective ideas than preschoolers across three creative tasks.
- Children reported greater confidence, motivation and enjoyment, especially when activities had no clear goal.
- Among adults, 78% believed children were more creative, while an earlier survey found the same view among 80% of respondents.
- Experts recommend giving children time, independence and room to direct their own play and creative activities.
Emily Liu’s daughter Rose, age 2, writes piano melodies, invents yoga moves and transforms mixing bowls and pacifiers into hats and jewelry. She also creates recipes, although Liu warns that some may involve rocks.
“Nobody’s told her it’s supposed to be done a certain way, or supposed to look a certain way,” said Liu, who lives in Atlanta. “Creativity stems from that kind of autonomy, independence and innocence that comes with being a young child.”
That freedom helps explain why many people believe children are more creative than adults. Yet research published recently in PLOS One suggests the distinction may involve confidence and enthusiasm rather than creative ability alone.
The study found that adults were not less creative than preschoolers. Grownups generated ideas that researchers considered more novel and effective, while preschoolers showed greater confidence and enthusiasm, particularly during activities without firm goals or constraints.
Researchers assigned three creative tasks to 92 children and 70 adults. Participants drew a mythological creature, proposed unusual uses for a tin can and completed a drawing of anything they wanted.
Their work was evaluated for novelty, effectiveness and overall creativity. Adults outscored children across all three measures, with their advantage especially apparent during the tin can and mythological creature assignments, which included specific goals.
Study coauthor Mathias Benedek, a researcher at the University of Graz in Austria, said the results indicate that creativity benefits from greater cognitive and metacognitive control. Still, ability does not guarantee that someone will express creative thinking.
“Even if you’re a super creative thinker, you might not actually show it if you don’t feel encouraged, or if you’re fearful that your ideas might get rejected,” Benedek said.
Children described a more positive experience during the activities, reporting greater confidence in their abilities, motivation, enjoyment and self appraisal. Adults reported more anxiety about whether they would perform well.
“Children really thrived when there was no clear goal — for example, the creative drawing task, they really liked that most,” Benedek said. “Adults didn’t feel comfortable when they had no clear goal in the task. They really wanted to understand what they were supposed to do.”
Before the tasks began, researchers asked participants whether children or adults were more creative. Children divided evenly on the question, but 78% of adults said children were more creative, echoing a survey in which 80% of adult respondents expressed that view.
Maryam Abdullah, parenting program director of the Greater Good Science Center at the University of California, Berkeley, said people may define creativity in different ways. Some may associate it with emotional or experiential creativity rather than with the sophistication of an idea.
Liu, who also has a son, age 9, encourages Rose by asking open ended questions and allowing her independence. She remains convinced that children are more creative because they are less concerned about judgment, social expectations or a correct way to complete an activity.
“There’s an innocence about them. They haven’t been impacted by society yet,” Liu said. “They’re not worried about social norms, they’re not worried about being judged or what the right way to do something is. They’re just doing what comes naturally to them.”
Sandra Russ, a distinguished psychology professor at Case Western Reserve University and the author of a book about creativity and play, said most researchers would reject the widespread belief that children are more creative. She emphasized that adults can nurture creativity by providing time and space for independent, unstructured activity.
“If they want you to engage with them — draw with them, play with them — do it,” Russ said. “But let them make up the story, let them make up the drawing. Don’t interfere.”
Russ said creativity among children ages 4 through 9 often appears through pretend play involving dolls, cars, building blocks or other toys. During the preteen years, it can become more cognitive, appearing through daydreaming, an invented science project or a distinctive approach to a math problem.
Abdullah said adults should first notice and affirm children’s creativity. Simply telling children that thinking outside the box has value can encourage them to display more creative behavior.
“The study asks, ‘Are children really more creative than adults?’ And the findings answer that question,” Abdullah said. “But what it asks that’s more interesting is, ‘Are children creative more often than adults?’”
Are you feeling overwhelmed or hopeless right now? Have you been withdrawing from people or activities you usually enjoy? Are you having thoughts about hurting yourself, or feeling like things will never improve?
You do not have to handle those feelings alone. Support is available, and talking to someone can make a difference. You can reach out to the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline by calling or texting 988, or by chatting online at 988lifeline.org. Trained counselors are available 24 hours a day to listen and help.
If you believe someone is in immediate danger, call emergency services right away. Even a small step, like reaching out to a trusted friend, family member, or professional, can help create a path forward.
Join the Discussion
COMMENTS POLICY: We have no tolerance for messages of violence, racism, vulgarity, obscenity or other such discourteous behavior. Thank you for contributing to a respectful and useful online dialogue.