WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW
  • Two biologists argue that de-extinction technologies cannot truly restore an evolutionary lineage once it has disappeared.
  • Colossal Biosciences made 20 edits across 14 genes in grey wolf cells to create animals with selected dire wolf traits.
  • Different methods, including back breeding, gene editing, cloning, and genome synthesis, preserve different degrees of biological connection.
  • The researchers say these technologies may better serve living species by preserving genetic variation, ecological interactions, and evolutionary potential.

Jurassic Park pushed the dream of reviving extinct species deep into the popular imagination. Yet two biologists from Wheaton College, Massachusetts, argue that even sophisticated new technology cannot truly restore a species once its evolutionary lineage has disappeared.

In a new opinion piece, the scientists challenge the language surrounding de-extinction. They say the emerging technology can produce impressive results, but those achievements should not be framed as bringing a vanished species back from the dead.

Their criticism focuses on Colossal Biosciences and its claim that it functionally reversed the extinction of the dire wolf. The canid roamed the Americas between 250,000 and 10,000 years ago, according to the article.

The company compared ancient dire wolf DNA with DNA from living canids. It then made 20 edits across 14 genes in grey wolf cells before cloning the animals.

The resulting animals are genetically engineered grey wolves displaying some traits associated with dire wolves, the researchers argue. They are not true dire wolves shaped through generations of breeding, mutation, natural selection, and environmental influence.

The researchers describe the mistake of calling this de-extinction as “lineage-genome conflation,” meaning the assumption that reconstructing portions of an extinct animal’s DNA is equivalent to restoring the evolutionary lineage to which it belonged.

Their objection is not directed at the basic scientific work, which they believe could have genuine value. Instead, they criticize the terminology used in “high-profile announcements and widespread media coverage.”

“Our criticism here refers primarily to the commercial and public-facing claims of literal species revival, rather than to the more qualified terminology generally employed in peer-reviewed scientific and conservation literature,” the study authors write.

Do you get at least seven hours of sleep most nights?

By completing the poll, you agree to receive emails from Being Healthy News, occasional offers from our partners and that you've read and agree to our privacy policy and legal statement.

“This framing nevertheless raises a deeper conceptual issue: while genomic engineering may reproduce selected traits inferred from extinct organisms, it does not necessarily restore the historical lineage from which those traits were derived.”

“Such organisms may have scientific or conservation value as analogs or ecological proxies, but they are not continuations of extinct lineages,” they added.

The scientists emphasize that technologies commonly grouped under the de-extinction label recover different things. Clear descriptions of the methods matter because each approach has different biological limitations.

Back breeding and gene editing both begin with animals belonging to living lineages. For that reason, the researchers argue, animals created through those methods cannot become the extinct species itself.

Cloning from preserved cells or embryos presents a different case because the biological material came directly from the original population. Animals produced this way would retain a genuine biological connection to the lost species.

Synthesizing genomes from ancient specimens could restore more of the missing genetic variation. Even then, the resulting population would be assembled from genetic information rather than descended from living animals belonging to that extinct lineage.

“These technological distinctions matter because each pathway raises a different question about what, biologically, would count as restoration of a species,” the paper added.

The scientific definitions are only part of the controversy. Efforts to create animals resembling extinct species also raise ethical questions about whether revival should be attempted and what those animals might experience.

Animal welfare expert Dr Heather Browning from the University of Southampton discussed those risks with IFLScience in 2025. She suggested that de-extinction projects could conflict with the welfare of the animals they produce.

“You're talking about an animal that's used to a multi-generational group to pass down knowledge about how to behave, how to act around one another, how to find and extract food, but all of a sudden, your animal doesn't have any of that. You're essentially dealing with orphans,” Dr Browning told IFLScience.

“You risk very real psychological trauma as these [animals] would lack the security, stability, and interactions that they need when they're young in order to develop into healthy, independent animals.”

Neither the welfare concerns nor the researchers’ conceptual criticism means the technologies should be abandoned. The authors argue that the tools involved remain important, but their most immediate conservation value lies in helping species that are still alive.

“We argue here that the most immediate conservation value of these technologies lies not in claims of reversing extinction, but in preserving genetic variation, ecological interactions and evolutionary potential in species that are still alive,” they conclude.

The study was published in the journal Biology Letters. Its central warning is that reproducing selected traits from an extinct animal is not the same as recovering the lineage that made the species what it was.


Are you feeling overwhelmed or hopeless right now? Have you been withdrawing from people or activities you usually enjoy? Are you having thoughts about hurting yourself, or feeling like things will never improve?

You do not have to handle those feelings alone. Support is available, and talking to someone can make a difference. You can reach out to the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline by calling or texting 988, or by chatting online at 988lifeline.org. Trained counselors are available 24 hours a day to listen and help.

If you believe someone is in immediate danger, call emergency services right away. Even a small step, like reaching out to a trusted friend, family member, or professional, can help create a path forward.