WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW
  • Astronomers searching for planets found a hidden white dwarf orbiting a red dwarf 28 light years away.
  • The newly recognized Welopōʻai system contains a red dwarf and two white dwarfs.
  • The inner stars’ separation conflicts with expectations for how a massive star’s red giant phase affects nearby companions.
  • Mismatched age estimates and possible dust around the inner white dwarf may offer clues to the system’s history.

Astronomers searching for planets around a nearby red dwarf instead uncovered a remarkably faint white dwarf, revealing an unexpected triple star system only 28 light years away. The arrangement is so difficult to reconcile with current ideas about stellar interactions and evolution that researchers say they have no clean explanation for it.

The red dwarf, previously known as IRAS 21500+5903, initially looked ordinary. It has 42% of the Sun’s mass and requires a telescope to see despite its relative proximity, which is about 10,000 times farther than Voyager 1 has traveled in 50 years.

That closeness made the star a prime target for astronomers looking for subtle wobbles caused by an orbiting planet. “Instead, we found something much more surprising,” said Étienne Artigau of the Université de Montréal in a statement.

Astronomers can measure changes in a star’s motion relative to Earth down to a few meters per second, depending on a planet’s position. In this case, however, they detected variations approaching 16 kilometers per second, or 36,000 mph.

Such a dramatic movement could not be produced by a planet. After extended observations to confirm the signal and estimate the object’s mass, Artigau and his coauthors concluded that the red dwarf was being moved by an object with more than half the Sun’s mass.

“The unusual combination of high mass and very low brightness left only one plausible explanation: it was the remnant of a dead star,” Université Laval undergraduate student Charles-Antoine Parent said. “The most likely explanation was a white dwarf, although a neutron star or even a black hole couldn't be ruled out.”

Using the ‘Alopeke instrument on the Gemini North telescope, the researchers detected a white dwarf that was both extremely faint and very close to the red dwarf. Its light had been overshadowed even by the comparatively dim red dwarf.

The system was already known to be a binary, with another white dwarf orbiting farther from the red dwarf and therefore easier to detect. The newly identified object transformed that picture, making the system a triple.

Do you read nutrition labels before buying packaged foods?

By completing the poll, you agree to receive emails from Being Healthy News, occasional offers from our partners and that you've read and agree to our privacy policy and legal statement.

Binary stars are common, while triple systems are rarer but not extraordinary. The nearby Alpha Centauri system is also a triple, yet the newly studied arrangement appears unlike any other system within at least 100 light years.

The central puzzle is the separation between the two inner stars. White dwarfs are remnants of stars that have completed their life cycles, and low mass stars have not had enough time to reach that stage within the age of the universe.

Researchers calculated that the inner white dwarf began as a star 44% more massive than the Sun. Its passage through the red giant stage cut its mass by more than half, leaving it with 62% of the Sun’s mass.

A star of that original size expands to hundreds of times its initial dimensions during the red giant stage. Placed where the Sun is, its maximum radius would extend beyond Earth’s orbit.

Planets can be swallowed during such expansion, while companion stars may also become engulfed. Stars positioned somewhat farther away, while avoiding engulfment, are expected to spiral inward until their orbits last only days.

Yet the gap between the two inner stars is only slightly smaller than the distance between Jupiter and the Sun. “This system should not exist,” said Université de Montréal professor Patrick Dufour. “We have no clean explanation for how it got here. That is the question driving our next observations.”

Because both telescopes involved in the discovery are based in Hawai’i, the team gave the system a new name, Welopōʻai. The name means “path of family traits,” with the path referring to the inner dwarf’s unexpectedly circular orbit.

The outer white dwarf is four times as far from the other two stars as Neptune is from the Sun. That distance presents no challenge to stellar evolution models because the former star could have expanded to its maximum size without disrupting the inner pair.

The estimated ages deepen the mystery. The white dwarfs appear to be 9 to 11 billion years old, placing them among the galaxy’s oldest stars, while the red dwarf is unquestionably old but appears younger.

Researchers hope that reconstructing Welopōʻai’s history could reveal something important about a broader category of star systems. Hints of dust with unknown origins around the inner white dwarf may provide one clue.

The study was published open access in Astronomy & Astrophysics.